Attendee Limits on Wine Country Events Debated
One developer wants limits raised for the number of people allowed to attend special events. Some residents push back.
A developer with interests in Wine Country pushed today to raise the limit of people allowed at special events facilities.
Dan Stephenson, the chairman of the Rancon Group, urged county officials to raise the limit of people allowed to attend special events in Wine Country.
Rancon opened three wineries this year, collectively called Europa Village Wineries, Resort & Spa, and has plans to build 58 high-end houses in the surrounding area.
The Wine Country Community Plan requires a special events facility to have 20 acres, and it allows five guests per acre at events.
This limit is not "economically viable," he said during a meeting of the Wine Country Ad Hoc Advisory Committee at Wilson Creek Winery today.
The committee met for the last time today to put the finishing touches on a plan which aims to guide future development in Wine Country.
Stephenson was one of the first members on the advisory committee when it started two and a half years ago. "We got a gold mine in the wine industry out here, and we've never laid out the boundaries," Stephenson said.
The committee was then only six members, though it swelled to 19 in the following years.
When representatives of residents joined the committee, they began pushing to keep the region rural and prevent over-development.
To read about those efforts, click here.
During the meeting, Stephenson asked to have the limit increased to as many as 20 people per acre.
Parking problems
As it is, too many people park their cars along roads and in open fields when a winery holds an event, some committee members said.
"I'd rather keep it lower. They can get special permits for special events," Elisa Niederecker said after the meeting. "That's a lot of traffic coming through. You really need to keep a cap on it."
There is no way to keep several wineries from putting on special events at the same time, creating a potential traffic nightmare if left unlimited, she said.
Some committee members asked to change the policy to limit attendees only by how many parking spaces the facility has.
No changes were made to the plan in this regard to make it simpler to study the potential impact the plan will have on the local environment and quality of life, said Mitra Mehta-Cooper, the county's principal planner.
Noise pollution
Noise was also a concern for some residents.
"Oak Mountain is behind me, and they have a 100 people limit (for its special events), and it's way too loud," said Heidi Betz, an attendee at the meeting and a Wine Country resident.
Holding special events is essential for a winery to stay in business, Stephenson said during the meeting.
"We've been oversensitive to residents about noise," he said. "The pendulum has gone too far."
Special events are supposed to be a secondary use for a winery, according to the plan.
A winery's viability is not the responsibility of its neighbors, said Betz. "It's not fair to impose your business on other people around you," she said. "(Keeping the business afloat) is not my problem as a neighbor."
Supporting the increase
Some residents thought the increase was a good idea.
"I don't see a problem with it," said local resident Fred Bartz. He felt there was ample parking in the vast, rural Wine Country landscape to accommodate more people than five people per acre.
The limit makes it hard to put on an event, especially for smaller businesses, said Al Abbott, a Wine Country resident and budding winemaker.
A winery makes most of its money through special events and wine tasting rooms, he said. "There's no money in making wine."
Travis
4:38 am on Friday, September 30, 2011
I happen to know Heidi Betts, who complains often about the noise at Oak Mountain Winery. She did fail to mention that her, her husband, and their son have had a 8 year relationship with the owners of that winery when they ran a construction business. They are not strangers.
When the Betts business took a dive ( and Oak Mountains business went up ) they started to complain to the county
In my opinion, the neighbor isjust jealous. There is always 2 sides to every story.
Travis
11:44 am on Friday, September 30, 2011
I have attached a photo of Heidi Betts and her fam attending one of Oak Mountain Winery's events in 2008. They look like they are having a very nice time to me.
Deane
6:32 am on Friday, September 30, 2011
Special events are crucial, however, the number of guests per event needs to be based on the availability of parking, both on site and off site. If a winery is able to aquire off site parking with shuttle service, then I see no problem. You also have to take into account just how many people the facility can handle. Most wineries can easily accomodate 100 to 200 people with little problem, including the small wineries.
michael
7:44 am on Friday, September 30, 2011
If the wine country wants to continue to attract visitors they need to keep it as rural as possible. Turning the wineries into mini Disneylands would destroy the character of the landscape. Again it’s all about making MORE money.
Dorland Mountain Arts Colony
8:37 am on Friday, September 30, 2011
During this time of economic need in our valley, it's important that the wine country businesses stay viable. Provide for their parking, respect their neighbors...... but keep putting on those events!! Many of those events are fundraisers for our local nonprofits. They raise much needed money for our valley. And the more often and larger the events, the more jobs they create. We all need jobs in this valley and thankfully the wine country provides jobs!
Alex Sukhov
11:53 am on Friday, September 30, 2011
Our valley is in desperate need of cash flow to all of it's local businesses. We need to support ALL of the Wineries and local business, unless we want a higher jobless rate in our valley which is already suffering tremendously. It seems every time a developer has a good plan to increase jobs, some (few) loud mouth anti everything locals step up to stop them. I AGREE WITH INCREASING THE PLAN TO ALLOW MORE SPECIAL EVENTS. IT HELPS OUR LOCAL ECONOMY TREMENDOUSLY. All events have dates, if you don't like the idea of people going out to enjoy themselves, then leave town for the day and let our valley have some fun!!
Dawn
4:30 pm on Friday, September 30, 2011
What I have never understood is: Why in the ....... do people move into an area that they know will be high traffic and high in outside events? Along with that. All outside events are under a 10:00pm shut down time. The noise shouldn't be a problem. I really wish that in this terrible economy we would all join together and support all business selflessly...
Kathy Klein
10:54 am on Saturday, October 1, 2011
Steve and Val at Oak Mountain have bent over backwards just to placate one neighbor "lady".Planting trees,soundproofing,enclosing the patio, etc. Ms Betts needs to get a hobby.