.
Feedback

TEMECULA PARENT: Lack Of Sidewalks On Pauba Road To Blame For Tragic Accident

“We want the city to call us and tell us where the missing sidewalk is,” said Mike Baxter, father of one of the young women struck by a car March 11 on the busy road.

Two female pedestrians who were struck by a car in their neighborhood along Pauba Road after a trip to the Temecula Public Library are still recovering from their injuries.

Meanwhile, their parents want to know when sidewalks will be installed along the city street in order to prevent future accidents.

“We want the city to call us and tell us where the missing sidewalk is,” said Mike Baxter, father of the 19-year-old woman who was struck the evening of March 11 along the busy road.

Baxter’s daughter and her 22-year-old friend were walking westbound in the bicycle lane of the westbound side of the road when they were hit by a Toyota Matrix piloted by a female driver with two young children in the car.

According to police, the glaring sun temporarily affected the driver’s visibility; the two women were struck shortly after 5:30 p.m.

“The driver was traveling directly into the setting sunlight …,” Sgt. Jon Wade of the Temecula Police Department reported. “As the driver transitioned from having direct sunlight in their eyes into the shaded area, the driver drifted into the bicycle lane and struck two female pedestrians who were walking westbound within the bicycle lane.”

Baxter’s daughter sustained serious injuries from the incident and is still hospitalized. She suffered broken bones and a concussion; once she is released from the hospital, she faces months of rehabilitation, he said.

The 22-year-old woman who was struck suffered moderate injuries and is expected to make a full recovery. There were no reports of injuries to the driver or the children in the vehicle.

Baxter, his wife Melanie, and the mother of the 22-year-old woman who was struck, walked the trek along Pauba Road Thursday evening. They pointed out the lack of sidewalk, the weedy parkways on either side of the road, protruding trees and bushes that force pedestrians into the bicycle lane, and the high speed of traffic in the area.  

“We have all these nice things in Temecula and we can’t do a sidewalk so people can walk here safely?” Mike questioned.

The two women were struck approximately a half-mile west of the library located at 30600 Pauba Road.

The library is surrounded by tract homes, which the Baxters say are filled with families with young children. The couple has lived in the neighborhood as a family for about 10 years, Mike said.

“It’s the same problem for the kids here who walk to Vail Elementary School,” he said. “They don’t have sidewalks here either.”

The City of Temecula was contacted for this story. Interim City Manager Aaron Adams said all accidents on public property are reviewed but he provided no comment on the March 11 incident.

The Baxters said they have reached out to City, but as of Saturday morning had received no response.

According to Temecula’s Chief of Police Andre O’Harra, there has not been a high number of incidents on the Pauba Road stretch where the women were hit, about a half-mile west of the library.

Mike disagrees.

“It’s a very dangerous road. Does it take somebody getting killed first?”

Watch the attached video to hear and see more of the interview with Mike Baxter.

Katie March 18, 2013 at 05:28 pm
I drive that stretch quite frequently and have also noticed the sun being a problem with visibility. I hope that they do add sidewalks to make it safer for pedestrians. It could save a life!
Brenda March 18, 2013 at 07:06 pm
This article and the fathers statements are spot on. Why would we NOT have a sidewalk on a high traffic street? That alone is the question we need to ask the City. Its like someone "just" forgot to put it there?
Also this is a street of running stop signs, speeding everytime I have the misfortune of being on it. If there have not been additional accidents it must be a miracle cause probably 25% of the people driving on it are breaking a law. If the Baxters need signatures for this to get done get a location and the Patch can put in the story where we need to go and sign. This is outrageous this happened, and I hope they have investigated the "sun" story because who swerves into the bike lane unless they are speeding. Even with the "sun" you know if you are in the lane or not or are swerving out of it. My two cents and having driven 37 yrs with a license in all weather conditions. I hope both girls make a speedy recovery and its a true miracle they are alive to tell their story and plead with the City about the "invisible" sidewalks.
Mike Gordon March 18, 2013 at 08:13 pm
I live less then a 1/2 mile from where this happened and have been here for 17 years and know exactly where this happened. I have wanted sidewalks there since day one and even more after they put in the library. It makes no sense not to finish up the missing link and the city needs to step up to the plate already. That being said though the girls should not have been walking on that side of the street going in that direction. This is the exact reason why you walk against traffic not with it! When you walk against traffic you can see the cars coming at you and when you walk with traffic you just asume that the cars see you on the side of the road. I'm not saying that it is the girls fault at all, it was a terrible accident and neither the driver or walker should have been put in that situation. Shame on the city for waiting this long, and who knows how much longer for them to remedy the situation.
Mimi March 18, 2013 at 09:05 pm
I thought the same thing, Mike, when I read about the direction they were walking. Not to place blame because what happened is awful. I just don't know if people are even aware of this tip. I live in a neighborhood with no street lights. I see people out walking at dusk with their dogs, kids and families and they all have their backs to the oncoming traffic. Older people (like 60 and above) however? Always walking head on into it. Interesting, huh?
Fauntleroy Murphy March 18, 2013 at 10:14 pm
Be careful addressing the City Council about this issue. Remember, if you want sidewalks you must address the council as if they are kings and queens. Be humble and stroke their ego's.
Bryan C. March 19, 2013 at 12:11 am
I agree for the need of sidewalks. However, it irritates the S*** out of me to see sidewalks and the people that choose to walk in the street! Especially runners.
sue grafton March 19, 2013 at 12:33 am
It always seems to me like bicyclists should ride against the traffic, therefore at least being able see whats coming at them. When riding with the traffic cars in general drift towards what they see on the side of the road, running over bicyclist from the back. Not saying this has any to do with this accident, just sayin'. Speedy recovery to both women.
xiphiasallure@aol.com March 19, 2013 at 01:31 am
all so true - there are many streets in Temecula tha are like this -- the city is to busy planting trees and figuring out how to make money !! The roads in soem communities are in terrible shape - the sun sets are also very dangerous -
On the right side March 19, 2013 at 02:20 am
The city seems to think that it is MORE IMPORTANT to build dividers, trees in the medians etc so that they "agree with the MASTER PLAN " . An example is Meadows Parkway. The painted lines worked just fine, but they had to put in dividers, trees, irrigation , etc because that is what was in the "MASTER PLAN". Another example is in front of the Paseo Del Sol community center. They tore up a good divider with trees and irrigation to add a turn lane that is seldom used. Again the reason given " to meet the city MASTER PLAN". There are examples like Pauba throuhout the city where roads suddenly stop and the start again. Each one of these locations are an accident waiting to happen. Is there ANY COMMON SENSE in city hall? I really doubt it.
dwc March 19, 2013 at 11:20 am
I used to walk that area (to library and back). I had one close call in that same area. Goes from 1 to 2 lanes. Young girl was in a hurry I guess, cut to the right lane too early and I could feel the tug as her mirror hit my sleeve. She never once looked at me, and there wasn't any sun causing problems at that time. Sidewalk is needed!
RunnerGal March 19, 2013 at 11:38 am
You're obviously not a runner! Concrete is much more dense than asphalt, and, therefore, much more painful and wearing on your body mile after mile. I do agree, however, that it's the runners' responsibility to use extra caution and be considerate to the vehicles on the road.
JJ Mclure March 19, 2013 at 11:44 am
you fools vote them in
Mike March 19, 2013 at 12:11 pm
There to busy spending $ on new buildings and paying off low income housing developers.
City is going down hill Redwahk is getting home invasion robberies , helicopters circling , heard a gun clip being emptied in the neighbor hood , 911 confirmed other callers Also heard the gun. Never saw a police car....... Redhawk parkway still needs stop signs and maybe rumble strips ,, how many more fatalities on Redhawk ? Maybe it should be called Redblood parkway
jas468 March 19, 2013 at 12:20 pm
Bicycles have to follow the same vehicle code as far as driving on the right side of the street as automobiles. But I get what you're saying.
LifeinTtown March 19, 2013 at 01:21 pm
The only reason any of the sidewalks are there on Pauba was because the developer was required to put them in - look where they are, fronting the church property and the along the houses at the top. When the houses were built closer to Ynez, the county (at that time) obviously didn't have the codes in place to pass the responsibility on to the developer. The only reason there are sidewalks in front of the library and other city property (between the library and the church) is because the city was bound by their own codes when it was built. There will never be sidewalks there because the city won't pay for them because they will claim it's not their responsibility. Petitions won't help (duh) because the city leaders don't care.
LifeinTtown March 19, 2013 at 01:23 pm
I live in Redhawk and heard the gun shots - about 15 minutes later there were two police cars in my neighborhood driving around.
More patrolling in the morning to get all of those crazy mom's driving their kids to GOHS would help - almost impossible to get out of my neighborhood onto RH Pkwy.
Susan Marsh March 19, 2013 at 02:00 pm
Besides the vehicle code, bikes ride with the follow of traffic because it they are hit they are propelled further in the direction they were going instead of two objects coming towards each other at whatever speed and slamming into each other. Less damage is caused by both heading in the same direction. It is physic
sam March 19, 2013 at 02:45 pm
Sick City Council ! ! ! This is just the tip of the ice burg. People need to attend City Council Meetings and find out what's going on. They are currently voting to bring in Convicted Criminals and Mentally Dangerous people into Stack'em and Pack'em housing here in Temecula claiming it's a State Law. CITIZENS MUST FIGHT THIS CITY HALL THAT ALLOWS ABORTION CLINICS, INVITES CRIMINALS AND SUPPORTS AGENDA 21.
Diane Johnson March 19, 2013 at 05:16 pm
Sam, Abortion is legal, they cant stop clinics just because the religious groups and you dont agree. Try to stay on topic here...SIDEWALKS
Larry Cawhorn March 19, 2013 at 08:14 pm
What is the topic? The safety of individuals is the Master topic...or should be. Lack of sidewalks is this time. Speeding, rolling stops, running traffic lights, zipping in and out of lanes, racing, As we know if the speed limit is 55 the drivers are doing 60-65. This even on single lanes. The sun is blinding at times but we can not control nature. So the question remains, What can we as a community do? For all (myself encluded) stop talking and take action. Go to the city meetings and if are not satisfied with those leaders...step up, join togather and remove them. I am sorry for those hit and pray God and Jesus will give them quick recovery.
PD March 19, 2013 at 09:32 pm
This is tragic. Its so easy to blame City Council but its OUR OWN FAULT! Why don't we pay attention to these matters before people get hurt? Safe sidewalks and bike lanes shouldn't be an afterthought. This is just one of many stretches around town that are highly risky because most of us just don't care about pedestrians & bicyclists until its one of our own that gets hurt!
Slow down. Obey the traffic laws. And demand that Temecula be a pedestrian & bike friendly city!
Brenda March 19, 2013 at 10:28 pm
Jeeeshush guys, we need to press the police about this. IT happened right in our neighborhood about 2 months ago. After shooting every kind of gun all my life I know what it sounds like when someone takes a few pot shots and then empties a clip. Called the PD, and we hit the floor it was that close.
Never heard a damn thing back from them, and now I hear of two more incidents of this happening. These rifles can easily spew bullets thru 4 or 5 houses before stopping. We obviously have someone trying to make a statement. LifeinTtown, I dont think one single main street was designed properly in T-Town and continue to only get worse.
Brenda March 19, 2013 at 10:35 pm
PD, exactly. Also I am not sure I agree with people having to walk against traffic to each other sees each other. If someone is going even 15 mph its hard to "jump" out of the way of that vehicle. If sidewalks were in it would not be a subject here even that anyone was walking the wrong way.
Does this also mean that if a sidewalk was in place that the driver of the car would NOT have went up onto the sidewalk if her vision was so horribly blocked that she could not see these girls? Then the girls would not have been hit? I guess the real question I want to see is if there is truly a problem with the sun at exactly that location at exactly that time which caused this accident or was it driver error? Has anyone went to check? By rights if she was completely blinded and swerved that far she would have ended up in the bushes.
Brenda March 19, 2013 at 10:39 pm
Off topic but you are right Sam.
I pray that we do NOT get anymore criminal activity then we already have. The City has to see where we are going downhill as it is with the daily crime reports. Let them be built elsewhere as we do not pay taxes on 750-1 million homes to be invaded by even more criminal activity and our children lost to drugs and murder.
Janny March 20, 2013 at 12:36 am
I was just moments behind the accident but was turned around by police. I distinctly remember also being totally blinded by the sun. Just was glad I didn't leave my house a few minutes earlier or it could have been me, though I consider myself a very cautious driver. Best wishes to the girls, but I agree about walking AGAINST traffic - that's how I was taught growing up.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Temecula Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
Masterpiece Band at Cellarz93 Restaurant Winehouse
djschristensen3 June 9, 2013 at 09:35 am
Was that the grand finale ? Cellarz93 is closed now. So sad, a wonderful gem in the Valley.
LAKE ELSINORE RESIDENT May 28, 2013 at 12:19 pm
Watch this video, it's directly across the street from a large aggregate mining operation. thinkRead More crystalline silica. Aggregate trucks drive in front of this club constantly it's a haul road. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhckrqXX-L4
Brenda June 2, 2013 at 02:58 am
All comes down to getting the "GOLD" Balanced right in the big City Hall right? We areRead More broke we are broke! We have how many more million dollar residents, ranches, farms who pay taxes, how many more business's, triple, quadruple, on and on that pay taxes, and some very large business's at that for YEARS. Yet Murietta and Menifee with just the few they have can manage to not only put in side walks, AND ALSO ACTULLY Listen their residents, instead of call them names like Paul has been, concerns and respond to them. Hell we are just now getting some attention to our driving issues with running red lights, speeding, not stopping at stop signs, driving drunk, high, or wreeklessly causing deaths and serious injuries to walkers, bike riders, skate board, scooter riders, wheelchairs, motor bike riders, and other cars. But how many lives were lost or severly disabled until we just now the last 2 weeks have been giving traffic details for different areas, cell phone details, etc. Lucky to get some sidewalks finished in 10 years if someone doesnt figure out where our "Gold" is we all pay in. And stop calling names people at the City meetings to Paul or anyone else trying to get our City to do what its there for. By the time someone in your own family is killed they will be laughing at you for standing up asking for sidewalks right? Just like on the "Patch" comment areas, always calling names instead of sticking with your fellow Temeculites and getting us something DONE! Before we loose more lives